- 24-hour Emergency Line: 0300 30 32 442
A departmental dispute arose at the NHS Foundation Trust following the announcement of a change to the pay banding structure for doctors. Dr X and their colleagues were informed by email that their roles would be re-banded from Band A to Band B. This alteration was met with unanimous opposition from the entire department.
Dr. X, who was not a BMA member (unlike their colleagues), reached out to MDS for guidance. Their objective was to inquire if MDS could coordinate with the BMA to ensure a unified and consistent strategy among all involved doctors, thereby strengthening their collective stance.
MDS asked Dr X for a copy of all correspondence and contractual documentation related to the proposed banding change and established a clear timeline to confirm whether appropriate notice was given by the Trust. MDS also reassured the member that any significant alteration to contractual terms, such as a change in pay banding, generally requires proper consultation and sufficient notice, generally of at least six weeks, to allow staff to respond adequately and consider their options.
MDS sought confirmation of the date the Trust informed the doctors of the proposed change. This was to verify compliance with the contractually mandated six-week notice period, as such procedural adherence is vital when implementing significant contractual alterations.
Following significant opposition from the department, the Trust ultimately withdrew its proposal to change the banding, resulting in an amicable resolution of the dispute. After the Trust retracted the banding change, MDS advised Dr. X to seek written confirmation from the Trust. This confirmation would ensure that no future changes would be made without adequate consultation and notice, thus safeguarding the doctor’s interests.
Regarding the query about liaising with the BMA, MDS clarified that although we have a history of working alongside the BMA on distinct but related issues, in this case MDS’s support was primarily individual, as Dr X was the only MDS member involved.
MDS recommended Dr X to encourage their colleagues to engage their union (BMA) to ensure a coordinated and strong collective response while continuing to provide Dr X with personalised support. This approach respected the roles of each organisation and avoided duplication or conflicting representation.
It is crucial to understand your contract’s terms, particularly the necessary consultation and notice periods. Major modifications, such as changes to pay banding, require a reasonable timeframe for staff engagement and response and cannot be unilaterally imposed.
Maintaining meticulous documentation of all correspondence with the employer is critical for building a strong case and protecting your rights. Emails, letters, and meeting records form the basis of evidence should disputes arise. For doctors who are members of different organisations, clarifying the roles and limits of each organisation’s involvement can prevent confusion or diluted advocacy.
Responding quickly and professionally to one’s employer helps prevent issues escalating unnecessarily and fosters a climate conducive to negotiation. This case also underscores the importance of pursuing amicable resolutions where possible. Open and constructive dialogue, backed by a clear united stance, can encourage employers to reconsider and resolve disputes without prolonged conflict.
After resolving a dispute, it is prudent to obtain written confirmation that no changes will be made without due process in the future, providing additional security and clarity.
Overall, the doctor’s experience highlights that knowledge, preparation, unity, and clear communication are key to successfully managing employment challenges.
Find yourself in a similar situation? Need help crafting a patient complaint response? Contact MDS as soon as possible to discuss your situation, our team will support you in making the best decision for you and your patients. Call our office on 0300 30 32 442 or email or case managers at [email protected] mentioning your membership number.
Not an MDS member? Get in touch and join today!
